UFA 09-025 File: Forest Declassification and the CAMVERT Agro-Industrial Project in Campo-Ma’an
  • Date de Publication : 2026-10-15

I would like to thank you for the interest your newspaper takes in the management of the national forest estate and for the opportunity this gives me to provide the Administration’s perspective on this matter, which has generated considerable commentary and, at times, inaccurate statements. As is customary, I will address this issue from a legal standpoint, since State actions must be assessed against the laws and regulations of the Republic. I would like to make it clear from the outset that this case was examined and decided under Law No. 94/01 of 20 January 1994 and its implementing instruments, which constitute the applicable law governing the actions in question. Law No. 2024/008 of 24 July 2024 governing forests and wildlife, which succeeded the previous law and repealed its conflicting provisions (Article 190), did not overturn these rules; rather, it confirmed them and strengthened them in several respects. I will therefore refer to it whenever it helps clarify the continuity of State action.

1. ON THE DECLASSIFICATION PROCESS AND LAND CONTINUITY

Allow me first to clarify a fundamental point. No portion of UFA 09-025 was “removed” from the permanent forest estate outside the law. It underwent declassification, that is, a procedure provided for, regulated and sanctioned by the applicable legal instruments. Law No. 94/01 of 20 January 1994 governing forests, wildlife and fisheries distinguishes between the permanent forest estate, comprising “land permanently allocated to forests and/or wildlife habitats,” and the non-permanent forest estate, comprising “forest land that may be allocated to uses other than forestry” (Article 20). The transition from one category to the other is not prohibited; it is subject to conditions and regulated. The 2024 law retains this framework: Article 21 distinguishes between the permanent forest estate, “comprising land permanently allocated to the protection and sustainable management of forest and wildlife resources,” and the non-permanent forest estate, “comprising land within the national domain that may be allocated to uses other than forestry.” Article 17(1) expressly provides that “the clearing of all or part of a classified forest is subject to the total or partial declassification of that forest.” This is precisely the process followed in Campo.

As regards the reasons for the decision, Article 22 of Decree No. 95/531/PM of 23 August 1995 laying down the implementing provisions for the forest regime stipulates that the declassification of a State forest from the State’s private domain “may only take place for reasons of public interest.” In this case, the public interest is established: reducing the country’s structural deficit in crude palm oil, which weighs on our trade balance and household purchasing power; creating direct and indirect jobs in a department where young people are looking for opportunities; improving access to and infrastructure in a rural area; and, lastly, contributing to the objectives of the National Development Strategy 2020–2030 (NDS30), which makes import substitution a government priority. It should also be recalled that the area concerned, which had been developed by SCIEB for decades, had already been subject to logging operations. The 2024 law further confirms that declassification remains an exception: Article 26(1) permits it only for a permanent forest “recognised as having no utility in view of its initial allocation” and in accordance with procedures established by regulation. Article 22 also stipulates that permanent forests “may neither be alienated nor be subject to any form of allocation” in this capacity, making a declassification decree an indispensable prerequisite for any conversion.

Regarding the criteria, Article 9 of the aforementioned Decree of 23 August 1995 establishes limits that the Administration may not exceed. Declassification may not take place where clearing would jeopardise the satisfaction of local populations’ needs for forest products, threaten the survival of neighbouring populations whose livelihoods are linked to the forest concerned, compromise ecological balances, or undermine national defence requirements. These criteria guided the examination of the case, particularly the delineation of the declassified area in such a way as to preserve the integrity of Campo-Ma’an National Park.

As regards the procedure and safeguards, these were observed at every stage by the various administrations concerned, and each stage resulted in a written instrument included in the file. Once the public interest had been declared, the forestry administration conducted the assessment process in strict compliance with the applicable legal instruments. This process culminated in a meeting of the departmental commission provided for under Articles 19 and 20 of the Decree, which brings together the Senior Divisional Officer, sectoral administrations, elected representatives and traditional authorities. A decree by the Prime Minister, Head of Government, was subsequently sought on the basis of a file that had to include the commission’s minutes and “a description of the area to be classified as compensation” (Articles 23 and 24 of the Decree).

This description is not a mere formality: it implements the fundamental safeguard set out in Article 28(2) of the 1994 law, according to which no declassification may take place without the classification of a forest of the same category and equivalent area within the same ecological zone. This rule was complied with to the letter. The declassification of portions of UFAs 09-021 (approximately 70,000 hectares) and 09-025 (approximately 30,000 hectares) in the Campo area was offset by the classification of UFAs 07-005 (65,007 hectares) and 07-006 (68,385 hectares) in the Ebo forest massif as part of the State’s private domain, representing a total of 133,392 hectares, pursuant to Decrees No. 2023/01630/PM and No. 2023/01631/PM of 27 April 2023. The permanent forest estate has therefore not shrunk; it has expanded. At the same time, the reconfiguration of the former Campo UFAs into conservation forests increased the area of the Campo-Ma’an Operational Technical Unit (OTU) from approximately 800,000 to 900,000 hectares. The 2024 legislature expressly enshrined this safeguard in even stricter terms: under Article 26(2) of Law No. 2024/008, “the total or partial declassification of a forest may only take place after a forest of the same category and at least equivalent area has been classified.” The compensation provided in Ebo, which exceeds the declassified area by more than 33,000 hectares, therefore satisfies not only the 1994 law but also the stricter standard established by the new law. I would also point out that Article 24 of the new law now requires the classification decree to specify “cadastral coordinates duly linked to the national geodetic network,” while Article 184 confirms that forests classified under previous regulations “shall remain so classified.” The Ebo UFAs 07-005 and 07-006 are thus durably secured within the permanent forest estate.

Finally, once declassification has been ordered, Article 22(3) of the Decree specifies that “the land concerned shall be managed in accordance with the applicable land tenure regime.” The allocation of the land to the project developer therefore falls under land tenure legislation and the administration responsible for state property and land affairs, with its own set of contractual specifications, while the project’s environmental compliance falls under the administration responsible for the environment. For its part, MINFOF retains control over the fate of the timber located within the project footprint: the timber is recovered “either through direct State management or through public auction, on the basis of inventory results” (Article 110 of the 1995 Decree), and each tree must be geolocated and identified by a barcode in the Forest Information Management System (SIGIF) before any recovery authorisation is granted (Article 30 of Order No. 0002/MINFOF of 7 February 2013). No cubic metre of timber may therefore leave the site without being traceable by the State. Moreover, the new law has made “the legality and traceability of forest products” and “the fight against deforestation and forest degradation” integral components of the forest regime itself (Article 1(2)). Article 61(2) also confirms that direct State management “may be undertaken where the recovery of the forest products concerned is necessary.” The arrangements implemented in Campo are therefore consistent with the framework the legislature intended to make permanent.

2. ON ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MONITORING AND PROXIMITY TO THE NATIONAL PARK

First, I wish to be absolutely clear: Campo-Ma’an National Park has not been declassified, either wholly or partially, and its area of 264,064 hectares remains intact. Under Article 8 of Decree No. 95/466/PM of 20 July 1995 laying down the implementing provisions for the wildlife regime, such an action would require a decree by the Prime Minister following submission of a file by the administration responsible for wildlife. Nothing of the sort has occurred. The CAMVERT project is located outside the protected area. The Park’s status is further reinforced by the 2024 law, Article 28 of which expressly includes national parks among State forests classified within the State’s private domain by decree; Article 22 prohibits the alienation of these permanent forests or their being “subject to any form of allocation”; and Article 184 provides that forests classified under previous regulations “shall remain so classified.”

With regard to the clearing observed through satellite imagery in 2020 and 2021, it is important to avoid conflating different issues. The law defines clearing as the removal of vegetation cover “for the purpose of assigning the land a non-forestry use” (Article 15) and permits it where it concerns an area that has been duly declassified (Article 16). A satellite detects a change in vegetation cover; it does not establish whether that change is legal or illegal. It is precisely the Administration’s role to make this distinction, and it has done so. Article 3 of the 2024 law essentially reproduces this definition: clearing means “the removal of trees or vegetation cover from forest land for the purpose of assigning it a non-forestry use, regardless of the means used for that purpose.” Article 17(2) of the same law also requires prior environmental and social impact assessments for any development project likely to disturb the forest environment, a requirement that the CAMVERT file has met, as I explain below.

The monitoring and oversight mechanisms take several forms. First, the conversion of the area was made subject to a detailed environmental and social impact assessment, in accordance with Articles 17 to 19 of Law No. 96/12 of 5 August 1996, the framework law on environmental management, and Order No. 00001/MINEPDED of 8 February 2016, which subjects any “mechanised agricultural operation covering an area exceeding 1,000 hectares” and any “oil palm plantation and associated oil mill” to such an assessment. This assessment must analyse the site’s initial conditions and set out measures to “eliminate, reduce and, where possible, compensate for” the project’s adverse impacts. Its environmental and social management plan is binding on the project developer. Second, the National Control Brigade and the South Regional Brigade, supported by the Ocean Divisional Delegation, conduct verification missions based on mapping alerts monitored by the Ministry’s technical services to ensure that no clearing extends beyond the boundaries of the declassified area. Third, the conservation service of Campo-Ma’an National Park conducts regular patrols and periodic wildlife surveys to monitor changes in populations of elephants, great apes and other emblematic species. These activities correspond precisely to those assigned to protected-area management under the 2024 law. Article 106 includes “wildlife population surveys,” “habitat mapping and zoning,” “monitoring and protection,” “research and ecological monitoring,” “anti-poaching measures,” “behavioural research and the habituation of great apes,” and “implementation of the environmental management plan.” Article 113, meanwhile, makes ecological monitoring—the collection of data “on the status and spatio-temporal trends” of animal populations and their habitats—an obligation of the administration responsible for wildlife, “for the purpose of guiding management decisions.”

With regard to elephants, I would remind you that they belong to Protection Class A: species in this class “are fully protected and may under no circumstances be killed” (Article 78 of the 1994 law). Any human-wildlife conflict arising from the proximity of plantations is therefore managed by my services in accordance with the prescribed procedures, excluding any hasty or expedient solution. The 2024 law fully maintains this regime. Article 110(2) stipulates that Class A species “are fully protected and may under no circumstances be killed.” Article 114 permits the administration responsible for wildlife, when dealing with dangerous animals or animals causing damage, only to “drive them away and, exceptionally,” to conduct “controlled culls.” Article 117 grants victims of damage caused by Class A and B animals a right to compensation. Article 173 provides for a prison sentence of fifteen to twenty years and a fine of CFA francs 20 million to 50 million for killing a fully protected species, while Article 157 excludes any settlement in such cases. As for the integrity of the ecological corridor, this is safeguarded through the comprehensive approach adopted by the Campo-Ma’an Operational Technical Unit (OTU), which makes it possible to assess the cumulative effects of different activities—logging, agro-industries and infrastructure associated with the Kribi industrial-port complex—at landscape level rather than on a project-by-project basis. The buffer zone, which the regulations define as an area “intended to mark a transition” between the protected area and zones where agricultural activities are carried out (Article 2 of Decree No. 95/466/PM), fully serves this purpose. This concern for ecological connectivity is now enshrined in law: Article 112 of the 2024 law defines an ecological connectivity zone as “an area located between two or more protected areas serving as a migration corridor for wildlife species” and provides for protection measures to be established by regulation. The concept of “forest landscape,” introduced in Article 3, likewise enshrines the landscape-level approach adopted by the OTU. The expansion of the OTU by nearly 100,000 hectares, which I mentioned earlier, is the strongest response to the legitimate concern you have raised.

3. ON COMPLIANCE WITH CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATIONS AND COMMUNITY RIGHTS

Neighbouring communities, including the Indigenous Bagyeli people, are central to our concerns, and the law leaves no room for improvisation. Article 8 of the 1994 law recognises the customary or use rights of neighbouring populations to forest, wildlife and fishery products for personal use. It further specifies that these rights may be suspended only “for reasons of public interest and in consultation with the populations concerned,” in accordance with the rules governing expropriation for public purposes. Article 26 requires that the social environment of Indigenous populations be taken into account and that any restriction of their customary or use rights be compensated.

In practical terms, consultation was organised at three levels. First, through the departmental commission established under the 1995 Decree, which includes traditional authorities and elected representatives of the populations concerned. Second, as part of the environmental and social impact assessment process, for which Decree No. 2013/0171/PM of 14 February 2013 requires the project developer to conduct public consultations with the populations concerned and, in the case of detailed assessments, public hearings organised by the environmental administration. Third, through local dialogue led by administrative authorities and my Ministry’s decentralised services. In this context, the Ministry ensures that subsistence areas, cultural and sacred sites, and the Bagyeli communities’ access routes to the forest are identified and preserved, and that customary and use rights continue to be exercised in the surrounding forest areas, including recognised customary-use zones on the outskirts of the Park.

These safeguards have been strengthened by Law No. 2024/008 of 24 July 2024 governing forests and wildlife. Article 1 expressly incorporates “the customary rights and use rights of neighbouring communities” into the forest regime; Articles 6 and 25 provide for compensation when use rights are restricted; and Article 7 establishes the communities’ right of pre-emption. The new law further stipulates that the suspension or restriction of use rights for reasons of public interest may take place only “after consultation with the populations concerned through their representative institutions” (Article 6(2)). It defines a neighbouring community as “local and/or Indigenous populations” living within or near the ecosystem concerned (Article 3), expressly encompassing the Bagyeli. It establishes participatory management as a guiding principle, requiring the State to guarantee “the participation of all stakeholders in the management of forest and wildlife resources” (Article 4) and to protect the forest estate “in collaboration with neighbouring communities” (Article 14). Finally, it allows communities, upon request, to obtain the classification of community protected areas “for cultural and/or socio-economic needs” (Article 33), an instrument that could be used to safeguard the cultural and sacred sites mentioned above.

The benefits for communities take two forms. The developer’s social obligations—including local employment, infrastructure and support for village plantations—are set out in contractual specifications that are legally binding on the developer and whose implementation is monitored. In addition, the recovery of timber from the project footprint gives rise to a recovery-products tax of CFA francs 2,000 per cubic metre, of which 30% is allocated to development infrastructure for neighbouring village communities and 70% to the municipalities concerned (Article 6 of Joint Order No. 0076/MINATD/MINFI/MINFOF of 26 June 2012). The 2024 law reinforces this approach: Article 141 stipulates that financial resources derived from the exploitation of forest resources contribute “to the financing of development projects of the State, Decentralised Territorial Authorities and populations.” Article 148 provides that the proceeds from public auctions of forest products are distributed, in particular, among municipalities and “neighbouring communities,” which must establish themselves as legal entities for this purpose—a process my services are ready to support. Finally, Article 188 provides that valid forest or wildlife exploitation permits must be supplemented by an amendment to their contractual specifications setting out the new management rules in compliance with the law. The requirements attached to forest permits in the area will therefore be updated accordingly. As we have recently done for other concessions, I will not hesitate to order a joint mission to verify compliance with social commitments, with the participation of administrative, municipal and traditional authorities. Any shortcomings identified will be addressed.

4. ON THE STRATEGIC VISION AND THE BALANCE BETWEEN THE TIMBER INDUSTRY AND AGRO-INDUSTRY

The Government refuses to set forestry against agriculture, as some would sometimes have us do. Cameroon is a developing country that must feed its population, create jobs and process its products locally, while honouring its international commitments on climate and biodiversity. The trade-off you refer to is therefore neither arbitrary nor made at the expense of the forest: it takes place within a legal framework that establishes clear limits.

The first limit is quantitative. Article 22 of the 1994 law stipulates that permanent forests “must cover at least 30% of the total area of the national territory”—a threshold retained in Article 23 of Law No. 2024/008, which adds the requirement that these forests represent “the country’s biological and ecological diversity.” Combined with the compensation requirement in Article 28, this provision ensures that any conversion of permanent forest is offset by an equivalent classification. The Campo case, compensated by more than 133,000 hectares in Ebo, illustrates this principle. The second limit is spatial: the allocation of forest resources must comply with the master plan for land-use planning (Article 16(3) of the 1994 law). Law No. 2024/008 now makes such allocation subject to a national land-allocation plan developed through a participatory process (Article 17(3)). Article 21(4) specifies that areas covered by the national forest estate “shall be indicated in a national land-allocation plan developed through a participatory process.” The third limit is environmental: no project of this scale may be implemented without a prior impact assessment (Article 16(2) of the 1994 law), and the precautionary principle enshrined in Article 9 of the 1996 framework law is binding on all parties. The 2024 law upholds this requirement by making “the implementation of any development project likely to cause disturbances in forest or aquatic environments” subject to prior environmental and social impact assessments (Article 17(2)).

From an economic standpoint, the comparison must be rigorous. The timber capital of a production forest can be harvested over successive rotations; it is not lost when a lawful conversion takes place, since the timber is inventoried, recovered and marketed for the benefit of the Public Treasury, municipalities and communities. Agro-industry, by contrast, creates lasting added value, permanent jobs and import substitution. The loss of ecosystem services is, in turn, offset by the classification of equivalent forest areas and the strengthening of conservation areas. It is this overall assessment, rather than a partial reading of the situation, that underpins public decision-making.

Is this model destined to expand throughout the South Region? The answer is no, if this means turning declassification into a policy. By legal definition, the permanent forest estate is “permanently allocated to forests”; declassification remains an exceptional procedure subject to the restrictive conditions I have outlined. New agro-industrial projects should primarily be directed towards the non-permanent forest estate and already degraded land, within the framework of land-use planning. Each application will be assessed on a case-by-case basis, taking into account public interest, impact assessments, community rights and the obligation to provide compensation. This is, moreover, the framework that the 2024 law has made even more stringent: the allocation of forest resources must be consistent with the national land-allocation plan (Articles 17 and 21); declassification requires the classification of an area at least equivalent in size (Article 26); and every permanent forest remains subject to its management plan, with which “all activities” must comply (Article 27). Cameroon, which allocates more than 30% of its territory to the permanent forest estate and whose production forests are largely under management plans, has no lessons to learn when it comes to balancing conservation and development. It simply intends to exercise its sovereign responsibility, in compliance with its laws, to make decisions that improve the living conditions of its population.

The Minister of Forestry and Wildlife